John Lydon has shut the door on the Sex Pistols again, and this time he has nailed it closed. In an interview published by The Sun to mark 50 years since “Anarchy in the U.K.,” the singer once known as Johnny Rotten was asked whether he could ever make peace with his former bandmates. His answer was that he would not, even if his life depended on it. “I’d rather die,” he told the paper, adding that he was not being dramatic.
It is the bluntest version yet of a position Lydon has held for years. What makes it land harder now is the timing. The single that started everything turns 50 this month, the band that carries the name is out on an anniversary tour, and the man who wrote the words is nowhere near it.
How a band that lasted three years is still fighting
The Sex Pistols were formed by guitarist Steve Jones and drummer Paul Cook, with Lydon joining as frontman in 1975. They released one studio album, Never Mind the Bollocks, Here’s the Sex Pistols, in 1977, and Lydon walked away after a show in San Francisco in January 1978. There were reunions later, starting with the Filthy Lucre tour in 1996, so the idea that these four men could never share a stage has been disproved more than once.
The current break is about something more recent. Jones’s memoir became the basis for Pistol, the Danny Boyle series that arrived in 2022. Lydon objected to the band’s music being used in it, and the dispute went to the High Court in London in 2021. The Sun’s account is that Jones and Cook sued Lydon after he opposed the plan, and that they won. The practical result, according to the paper, was that the other members gained the right to make decisions about the band over Lydon’s objections.
Accounts of who took whom to court do not line up neatly. MusicRadar’s report on the feud describes Lydon as the one who went to court to try to stop the show using the songs. Both versions end in the same place: Lydon lost, the series went ahead, and the relationship did not recover.
For Lydon, the legal defeat is only part of the grievance. His wife, Nora Forster, was living with Alzheimer’s disease while the case was heard, and he was caring for her full time. She died in 2023 after 44 years of marriage. He told The Sun that the case left him badly damaged financially at exactly the moment he was trying to look after her, that his former bandmates knew what he was going through, and that he regards it as a “wicked move.” That, more than any argument about royalties or legacy, is what he says he cannot forgive.
What the other three have said
The view from the other side is noticeably less heated. Steve Jones has said publicly that he would be open to a truce. In comments first given to The Sun and reported by MusicRadar in March 2025, Jones said a reconciliation “could happen” and that he had “no hard feelings towards John.” He also said the two had not spoken since 2008, and that he did not think holding on to resentment was healthy.
Glen Matlock, the band’s original bassist, has been more matter-of-fact. Asked by Billboard whether the group would welcome Lydon back, he said, as Radio X reported in May 2026, “It’s just not gonna happen.” Matlock also pushed back on the suggestion that a Pistols lineup without Lydon amounts to a tribute act, pointing out that three of the original members are on stage.
So the positions are these. Jones says the door is open. Matlock says a reunion will not happen but does not sound angry about it. Lydon says he would rather die. Nobody on either side is describing a negotiation, a meeting, or even a phone call.
The Pistols without Rotten
In Lydon’s place is Frank Carter, formerly of the punk band Gallows. The lineup of Jones, Cook, Matlock and Carter first played together in 2024 at a run of London shows to raise money for Bush Hall, and according to MusicRadar the response was strong enough that the band kept going. Jones has called Carter “brilliant.” The Sun reports the group is now on a 50th anniversary tour.
Lydon is not impressed, and in the same interview he was dismissive of his replacement and of newer bands he sees as imitating what the Pistols did. He has not been idle either. He has a memoir, Archive, in stores, he is on a spoken word tour of Britain, and The Sun says a twelfth Public Image Ltd album, Actual Intelligence, is on the way.
He also does not sound sentimental about the band he is refusing to rejoin. He told The Sun the whole experience was a “living nightmare” from the day he joined, though he allowed that it beat working in a factory.
That leaves an odd picture for the anniversary. The songs are being played to crowds every night by three of the men who recorded them, the fourth is touring separately and telling audiences his side, and the one thing all of them seem to agree on is that the original Sex Pistols are not getting back together.



