Elton John has picked another fight with a government over artificial intelligence, and this time the government answered within hours. A pre-recorded video from the singer played at Australia’s ARIA Awards in Sydney on Wednesday night, telling the country’s leaders they have “a duty to protect Australian artists and their work.” By Thursday morning, Acting Prime Minister Richard Marles was on live television defending Labor’s position, and telling News24 that the problem can’t be solved “by yelling at AI.”
It is the same argument Elton has been having with his own government for more than a year, and one every musician with a catalog has a stake in.
What Elton said, and where he said it
The ARIA message leaned on history. “Forty years ago I hosted the very first ARIA ceremony,” he said in the video, before turning to the point: “Don’t let AI use any Australian artist’s work without full permission. Please protect the next generation of Australian artists.” According to News24, the room answered with loud applause, and several other musicians raised the same concerns later in the ceremony.
The video was the gentle version. The sharper one ran in print. In an opinion piece for The Australian, quoted at length by News24, he warned that letting foreign AI companies use Australian creative work without permission would be an “epic self-inflicted error.” He wrote that some of those companies are “trying to strong arm the government” into a law that would let them train on music, film, books, journalism and photography without asking, and that “the Australian government appears to be listening.”
He also made a point he has made before: this is not really about him. “Established artists like me will be fine,” he wrote. The people he says would lose out are young songwriters and producers, along with stage crews, truck drivers and hairdressers — the working people around the music who can least absorb the hit. He closed by noting that the Prime Minister and the Attorney-General have both called themselves friends of music, and said they “should not be deceived” by AI companies into betraying that.
Some write-ups attach the “epic self-inflicted error” phrase to the ARIA speech itself; News24, which printed the video’s words in full, places it in the newspaper column.
The government’s answer
Marles was put on the spot by News24 host Pete Stefanovic, who opened with “The Rocket Man himself has you in his sights” and asked whether Labor had abandoned the creative and media industries.
Marles did not pick a fight back. He said creatives and news organizations should be “properly remunerated” and “completely compensated,” and that nobody could be satisfied with the status quo. “I definitely understand the sense of grievance that Elton John has,” he said. Then came the line that will annoy Elton’s side: “You can’t do anything about it by turning your back on it, by yelling at AI, by putting your head in the sand. You have to engage.”
That is the real disagreement, and both men stated it plainly. Elton’s camp wants permission first — no training on a song unless its owner says yes. The government says it wants artists paid, but frames the job as negotiating with the technology rather than shutting the door on it. News24 reports that AI developer Anthropic is among the companies pushing for an opt-out system, under which copyrighted work could be used to train AI models unless the owner explicitly objects. That is exactly the model Elton and the Australian industry are campaigning against.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, who was at the APEC summit in Shenzhen, had not responded to Elton directly when News24 published. A week earlier he had said his position was unchanged since July: artists “need to have control over their work” and “need to be compensated if their work is used.”
How it got here
Australia looked like it had settled this. According to The Nightly, the government ruled out a text-and-data-mining exception for AI training in October 2025. Tech companies kept lobbying, and the industry now fears a reversal.
This week that fear became a coordinated campaign. “Not AI’s To Take,” backed by Seven, Nine, News Australia, Foxtel and more than 30 industry bodies including ARIA and APRA AMCOS, launched with a takeover of the ARIA red carpet, according to The Nightly. Its demand is blunt: back existing copyright law and permanently reject any weakening. APRA AMCOS chief executive Dean Ormston put it this way: “A government’s job isn’t to shield AI companies from the consequences of taking creators’ work.” Readers should weigh one detail: News24, which broke the Marles exchange, belongs to the same News Corp family that is one of the campaign’s backers.
Elton is not the only rock star in the fight. Cold Chisel’s Jimmy Barnes told The Australian earlier this month that AI companies should, in News24’s asterisked version, “go f**k themselves.”
For Elton, the Australian row is a sequel. In 2025 he went after Britain’s Labour government over a similar opt-out plan, calling ministers “absolute losers” and accusing them of “committing theft,” as Far Out and others reported at the time. He signed open letters alongside Paul McCartney and Kate Bush and threatened to fight the proposals “all the way.”
What happens next
Nothing has changed in Australian law yet. The open questions are whether Albanese answers Elton personally once he is home from China, and whether the government’s talk of “engaging” with AI companies turns into a concrete licensing scheme — or into the opt-out model the industry is trying to head off. The campaign is pushing Australians to sign a petition and lobby their MPs.
Everyone involved claims to be on the artists’ side. The fight is over whether AI companies should have to ask first, or artists should have to object after the fact. Elton has made his side clear, in two countries now.



