Mick Mars’ legal fight with Mötley Crüe has reached what looks like its last stop. A Los Angeles Superior Court judge has confirmed the arbitration award that found the band was within its rights to remove its founding guitarist, and that leaves Mars owing his former bandmates $244,293.
According to MyNewsLA, Judge Teresa A. Beaudet granted the band’s request on Friday, November 20. The band had filed its petition to confirm the award back on January 27. The ruling turns a private arbitrator’s decision into a court judgment, which is the step that makes it enforceable.
How the numbers work
The figure is the result of two sums pointing in opposite directions. The arbitrator, retired federal judge Patrick J. Walsh, found that Mars owed the band $750,030 in tour advances he had been paid for shows he never played. Against that, the band owed Mars $505,737 for his 25 percent stake in Mötley Crüe Inc. Subtract one from the other and Mars is left with a bill of $244,293.
Variety, which obtained the ruling in January, reported how Walsh got to the larger number: the band had played 69 shows since Mars left, and each show recouped $10,870 per member. The valuation of Mars’ shares came from the band’s own expert. According to the ruling as quoted by Variety, Mars chose not to submit any valuation evidence of his own.
Walsh’s award was dated January 13 and became public at the end of that month. At the time, Variety noted it was still subject to confirmation by the Los Angeles court. That is the piece that has now fallen into place.
How a founding member ended up here
Mars, now 75, last played with Mötley Crüe in September 2022, at the end of the band’s stadium tour. He has ankylosing spondylitis, a chronic inflammatory arthritis he has lived with since his twenties. In his court papers he said the disease has fused his spine, left him three inches shorter than he was in high school, and made it impossible for him to turn his head.
His position was that he was retiring from the road, not from the band. He argued he was still available for recording, one-off shows and residencies, and should keep his full share. Nikki Sixx, Tommy Lee and Vince Neil took the opposite view: the band’s business is touring, and a member who stops touring has left. Mars went to court in April 2023, asking for the band’s business records and his legal fees. The band pushed the dispute into arbitration, citing a shareholder agreement from 1987.
Sixx explained the thinking behind that clause in a sworn declaration quoted by MyNewsLA. “A primary reason for this provision was to avoid putting the band’s disputes into the public realm where they would become subject to tabloid and media gossip,” he said. It did not work out that way.
In an interview with Variety in 2023, Mars said his bandmates had been “trying to replace me” since 1987, and he claimed parts of the band’s live show were pre-recorded. The band’s manager, Allen Kovac, told the same outlet that “Mick is not the victim.”
What the arbitrator said, and where accounts differ
The key document turned out to be a 2008 agreement stating that a member who did not tour would not share in the band’s stake. According to Walsh’s ruling, Mars himself had proposed it, after periods in which Neil and Lee had each been out of the band. “It seems inequitable that three members of a band would be subjected to the hardships of the road yet all four would share in the spoils,” Walsh wrote.
He was direct about what he was not deciding. Mars had argued it was immoral to cast him aside after four decades because of his age and his illness. “I am not unsympathetic to this argument,” Walsh wrote, “but it is not for me in the context of this arbitration to weigh in on the morality of the band’s decision.” He added that other bands have provided for founding members who stopped performing, and that he would have upheld such an arrangement had Mötley Crüe made one. They had not.
Walsh also accepted the band’s evidence that Mars’ playing had slipped on the 2022 tour, writing that at times he would play the wrong song or the wrong part, and that the band’s sound engineer would turn his guitar down and a pre-recorded track up when that happened.
One point is told differently depending on who is telling it. The band’s law firm said in January that Mars had been “forced to admit under oath” that his claims about pre-recorded bass and drums were false. MyNewsLA’s report says the arbitrator noted that Mars recanted those claims. Variety, which read the final award, reported that the ruling itself “does not detail” the recanting. Mars has not, in any report we have seen, given his own account of that testimony.
His side has not been quiet about the result, though. After the award became public, his attorney Ed McPherson told Billboard, in a statement quoted by Variety, that the band had been “fortunate to find an arbitrator who knows so little about the music industry and so little about the law.”
What happens next
MyNewsLA’s report does not include any reaction from Mars or his lawyers to Friday’s confirmation, and it is not yet clear whether he will appeal. Courts can only set aside arbitration awards on narrow grounds, which is why confirmation is usually the end of the road.
Mötley Crüe, meanwhile, has carried on with John 5 on guitar, and has spent this year marking its 45th anniversary. The band Mars named and helped start in 1981 now has a court judgment against him, and the question fans have argued about since 2022 is no longer a legal one. Whether it was fair is a different matter, and the arbitrator made a point of leaving that one alone.



