Christina Ricci says she and Cher are no longer in touch, and that the reason is a phone call she failed to return when she was 19. The actor told the story on Tuesday night’s Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen, and she told it against herself: by her own account, Cher was the one who reached out, and Ricci was the one who let it drop.
Asked by Cohen whether the two still speak, Ricci did not dodge. “I’m not. Unfortunately, she’s still mad at me, she holds a grudge,” she said, according to Us Weekly’s account of the episode. Cher has not responded publicly. HuffPost UK said it had contacted her team for comment.
The voicemail
The two met on Mermaids, the 1990 comedy-drama in which Cher played Rachel Flax, a restless single mother, with Winona Ryder and Ricci as her daughters. It was Ricci’s first film. She was a child at the time, and she has said for years that Cher looked after her on set.
The trouble, as Ricci tells it, came about a decade later. She said that she and Cher took part in a joint magazine interview when Ricci was 19, and that Cher said “all these things that were not that amazing about me.” Cher then phoned to smooth it over.
“Then she left me a voicemail about how journalists are always trying to get the worst things and blah, blah, blah, and she was so sorry, and I was 19, and so I didn’t return that message,” Ricci said.
Cohen put the obvious conclusion to her: Cher was angry that the call was never returned. Ricci agreed. She added that she has tried to make contact in the years since and has “gotten radio silence.”
It is worth being clear about what this is. Everything here is Ricci’s version of events. She did not name the magazine, and Us Weekly noted that it is unclear which publication ran the quotes. The same outlet pointed out that Ricci spoke to Rolling Stone in 1999, when she was 19, and credited Cher’s early support with helping her land the part of Kate Flax after six auditions. Nobody has produced the interview she is describing, and Cher has not given her side.
“I would be so pissed, I get it”
What makes the story unusual for a celebrity falling-out is that Ricci does not claim to be the injured party. She went out of her way to argue Cher’s case for her.
“I adore her, she’s the best and I absolutely, 100 percent, can imagine being Cher and being like, ‘Oh my god, they misquoted me and I’m going to call this young person and explain to her that they misquoted me,’ and then the gall of that young person to not return the call,” she said. “I would be so pissed, I get it.”
She then turned to the camera and addressed Cher directly, telling her she loves her.
That fits with how Ricci has always talked about her. In the 2024 documentary Child Star, she told Demi Lovato that Cher “took me under her wing” on the Mermaids set, as Entertainment Weekly reported at the time, and that she used to hide from her on-set tutor in Cher’s trailer. Cher, she said, understood that a child on a film set can pick up on tension behind the scenes and assume it is her fault. “She never wanted me to feel insecure,” Ricci said.
There was plenty of tension to pick up on. Mermaids went through three directors. Lasse Hallström left before filming, Frank Oz departed after clashing with Cher and Ryder, and Richard Benjamin finished the picture, according to the film’s production history. Emily Lloyd, originally cast as the older daughter, was replaced by Ryder and later sued. A ten-year-old in the middle of all that could have had a miserable time. By Ricci’s telling, Cher made sure she did not.
Cohen noted that Ricci had spoken warmly about Cher on his show before, which is partly why the answer landed the way it did. Until Tuesday, the public version of this relationship was entirely affectionate.
Where it goes from here
The timing gives the story extra reach. Cher, now 80, was announced this week for the Sunday “Legends” slot at Glastonbury 2027, which put her name back in headlines on both sides of the Atlantic on the same day Ricci’s comments spread. Ricci, 46, is promoting the fourth and final season of Yellowjackets, which is why she was on Cohen’s couch in the first place.
Whether Cher answers is the open question. She is not known for staying quiet when she has something to say, and a single post would settle whether this is a real grudge or a missed connection that has hardened over 27 years. She may also say nothing at all, which is its own kind of answer.
For now the facts are narrow: one actor’s account of a magazine interview nobody has identified, an apology left on a voicemail, and a call that was never returned. Ricci has made her move in public. The phone, as she sees it, is on Cher’s side of the table.



